Mario Games Tier List
Mario games span platformers, RPGs, kart racers and sports spin-offs. This board ranks the mainline and major spin-off games by design, replay value and historical impact.
The board
Mario Games starter board and community tiers
The starter board is dated and editorial. An item moves to its community tier after at least three votes; until then its starter tier stays visible.
The maker
Build your own Mario Games tier list
Start from this roster, add your own items, and share a board that is yours. Saving here does not change the public vote.
Unranked 0
Every roster item is ranked. Add your own below.
Live community vote
Rank every item on the roster
One vote per item per network. Voting again replaces your previous choice. Counts refresh every 15 seconds.
| Item | Starter | Community | Votes | Your vote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Super Mario Bros. 3 | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario World | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario 64 | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Galaxy | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Odyssey | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Bros. Wonder | S | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Galaxy 2 | A | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario 3D World | A | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Sunshine | A | — | 0 | |
| New Super Mario Bros. | A | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario 3D Land | A | — | 0 | |
| Mario Kart 8 Deluxe | A | — | 0 | |
| Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door | A | — | 0 | |
| Luigi's Mansion 3 | A | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario Bros. | A | — | 0 | |
| Super Mario RPG | B | — | 0 |
Top of the board
What the board currently rewards
No community votes yet. These are the starter picks from the editorial pass.
Method
How this page is built
01 · Starter board
One dated editorial pass
The ranking rewards games that still play well and changed the genre. A nostalgic game with rough controls sits below one that remains a benchmark.
02 · Community vote
Three votes to move
Votes are hashed by network, not stored with an email. An item only gets a community tier after three votes, so one visitor cannot flip the board.
03 · Trend check
Daily, and logged
A daily job checks Google Trends related searches for “tier list” and records the last successful run. It changes the queue and the score, never the roster silently.
What is Mario Games?
Mario games span platformers, RPGs, kart racers and sports spin-offs. This board ranks the mainline and major spin-off games by design, replay value and historical impact.
The ranking rewards games that still play well and changed the genre. A nostalgic game with rough controls sits below one that remains a benchmark.
This page is not an official ranking from a publisher or developer. It is a dated editorial board plus a public vote, and both are labelled. If a pick looks wrong, vote it down or publish a competing board with the maker.
Reference
What the tiers mean
| Tier | Meaning | When to use it |
|---|---|---|
| S | The best of the best | Reserve it for picks you would recommend without hesitation. |
| A | Excellent | Strong choices that just miss the top spot. |
| B | Solid | Dependable picks with a small catch. |
| C | Average | Works, but nothing stands out. |
| D | Below average | Only in specific cases. |
| F | The bottom band | Hard to recommend when alternatives exist. |
FAQ
Mario Games tier list questions
Are spin-offs included?
Yes, the major ones. A pure mainline board would drop Kart and the RPGs.
Why is Super Mario Bros. 3 S tier?
Because its level design and power-up system still hold up and influenced the genre. The board rewards lasting design.
What is the best Mario Games tier list?
There is no single authority. This page shows a dated starter board and a separate community vote, so you can see where the editorial ranking and the readers disagree. The maker lets you publish a third opinion in a few minutes.
How is this Mario Games tier list ranked?
The ranking rewards games that still play well and changed the genre. A nostalgic game with rough controls sits below one that remains a benchmark. The starter board is editorial, the community tier appears after at least three votes on an item, and neither is presented as official publisher data.
How often is the Mario Games tier list updated?
The site checks Google Trends every day for related searches and records the date of the last successful run. Editorial reviews are dated on the page. Community votes update immediately, so a stale starter board is still visibly separate from live opinion.
Can I make my own Mario Games tier list?
Yes. Open the tier list maker, pick this roster or add your own items, drag them into S through F, then share a link or download a PNG. No account is required to export an image.
What do S, A, B, C, D and F mean?
S is the top band: the picks you would recommend without hesitation. A is excellent, B is solid, C is average, D is below average, and F is the bottom band. The letters are a convention, not a scientific scale.
Is this Mario Games tier list free?
Yes. Browsing, voting and using the maker are free. There is no paywall on the board and no account wall on the PNG export.
Updates
Page history
Trend observations are recorded automatically. An editorial note appears here when the board is reviewed.
Go deeper
Guides for this board
S Tier Meaning: Why the Top Row Is Not Just “Best”
S tier does not mean “score S”. It is a grading convention with a specific job: marking the few picks that sit above the normal top band. Here is how to use it without emptying its meaning.
Read →How to Make a Tier List That People Actually Finish
Most tier lists fail before the first drag: too many items, no criterion, and no reason to share. A practical process for making a board that is fast to build and easy to argue with.
Read →Tier List Ideas for Gaming Communities
Eight board formats that work for game communities, from patch-day role rankings to beginner-friendly lists. Each one has a clear criterion and a reason for readers to respond.
Read →Site-wide
Trending elsewhere
Make your own Mario Games tier list
Start from this roster, rearrange it the way you actually see it, then share a link or a PNG.